firenum vs ProjectionLab: An Honest Head-to-Head
We built one of these two tools. Here's where ours loses.
Full disclosure at maximum strength: I build firenum. A comparison page written by one of the competitors is either the least trustworthy page on the internet or the most, depending on one thing: whether it names the places its own product loses. This one does, specifically and first.
Where ProjectionLab Beats firenum
- Tax depth. Both now compute US federal and state tax year by year (firenum since October 2026). ProjectionLab goes further: firenum always takes the standard deduction, files only jointly or single, skips local income tax and contribution limits, and computes tax for the US only. ProjectionLab has tax presets for other countries too. If your plan leans on itemizing, head-of-household status or a city tax, ProjectionLab is the better tool.
- Roth conversion planning. Both run conversion ladders with year-by-year tax. firenum offers four fixed strategies (fill a bracket, a fixed amount, stay under the ACA limit, none). ProjectionLab gives more control over each year.
- Scenario comparison. Premium's side-by-side compare mode (retire at 45 vs 50, with all charts duplicated) is the best in the category. firenum keeps up to 5 named plans in your browser and compares them in one table (when each retires, whether the money lasts on average returns, its Monte Carlo and historical backtest counts, net worth at retirement), with no side-by-side charts.
- Milestone storytelling. ProjectionLab's life-event timeline and progress views are more polished and more motivating.
Where firenum Beats ProjectionLab
- Price: $0 with taxes and several plans. ProjectionLab puts tax estimation, Roth conversions and multiple plans in Premium at $129/year (per projectionlab.com, 07-11-2026). firenum does all three at no cost. No account needed. The planner runs in your browser and your plan is saved there; a free account keeps it on any device.
- Privacy architecture. No account needed. The planner runs in your browser and your plan is saved there; a free account keeps it on any device. Delete the account and its plans go with it. ProjectionLab requires an account and stores plans in the cloud (with a good privacy reputation, to be fair).
- Multi-currency. firenum supports 9 currencies with real locale formatting (lakh/crore for INR, 万 for JPY). ProjectionLab's multi-currency request has been its most-voted open issue since November 2021.
- Cash-flow visualization. firenum draws a full Sankey diagram of where every dollar flows in any projection year, plus a Trinity-style portfolio survival heatmap across withdrawal rates.
- Stress testing. Six one-click scenarios: market crash with slower growth after it, job loss, spending spike, inflation surge, lower returns, retiring earlier or later. With Social Security in the plan, a seventh cuts the benefit.
Feature by Feature
| Capability | firenum | ProjectionLab |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $0, all features | $0 Basic / $129/yr Premium / $549/yr Pro for advisors; no lifetime tier (per projectionlab.com, 07-11-2026) |
| Monte Carlo simulation | Yes (100-5,000 runs, configurable volatility) | Yes |
| Historical backtesting | Yes, since 1872 (Shiller data) | Yes |
| Tax modeling | US federal, state and payroll, standard deduction only | Yes (Premium) |
| Roth conversions | Yes: fill a bracket, fixed, or under the ACA limit | Yes (Premium) |
| Scenario compare mode | Up to 5 plans, summary table | Yes (Premium) |
| Multi-currency | 9 currencies, locale formatting | Display currency only (symbol, no conversion) |
| Data storage | Your browser; a free account is optional | Cloud, account required |
| Multiple plans at $0 | Yes, up to 5 | No (Premium) |
| Sankey cash-flow diagram | Yes | No |
| Survival heatmap | Yes | No |
| Stress test scenarios | 6 built-in, plus a Social Security cut | Via manual what-ifs (Premium) |
| Withdrawal strategies | 3 + age-59.5 rule | Configurable withdrawal order |
| Mobile experience | Full feature set | Desktop-first |
The Simulation Engines Are Closer Than You'd Think
Both tools run drift-corrected Monte Carlo and both backtest against real historical returns. Both do the same job on the math that decides whether your plan survives. The bigger difference is between the methods, not the tools: Monte Carlo grades a plan by the return and swing you assume, while a backtest grades it by what markets actually did.
firenum documents its full methodology with derivations if you want to check the work. Both now run US taxes inside the engine. The differences that matter are around it: tax depth and polish on their side, privacy and currency handling on ours.
The Honest Answer: Many People Should Use Both
These tools charge differently because they're built differently. ProjectionLab pays a team through subscriptions and gives you tax-aware depth in return. firenum runs the math in your browser, so one more planner costs it next to nothing, and gives you privacy and breadth in return. A workflow I genuinely recommend:
- Do your everyday planning, check-ins, and stress tests in firenum: free, instant, saved in your browser or your free account. For a one-minute answer, the free FIRE calculator gives your retirement year.
- firenum runs a Roth ladder, a taxable sale or ACA subsidy planning with taxes on. When the decision needs itemized deductions, a filing status firenum lacks or a second opinion, model it in ProjectionLab : the $0 tier will show you whether the Premium depth is worth it for your case.
Verdict
If your US taxes are complicated (itemizing, head of household, a city income tax), pick ProjectionLab; our full ProjectionLab review rates it 4.5/5. If you want private, multi-currency planning with everything saved and nothing paid, pick firenum. If you're serious about early retirement, the combined cost of using both is $0 to $129 a year, which is a rounding error against the decisions they'll improve.
See the firenum side of the comparison yourself.