Full disclosure at maximum strength: I build firenum. A comparison page written by one of the competitors is either the least trustworthy page on the internet or the most, depending on one thing: whether it names the places its own product loses. This one does, specifically and first.

Where ProjectionLab Beats firenum

Where firenum Beats ProjectionLab

Feature by Feature

CapabilityfirenumProjectionLab
Price$0, all features$0 Basic / $129/yr Premium / $549/yr Pro for advisors; no lifetime tier (per projectionlab.com, 07-11-2026)
Monte Carlo simulationYes (100-5,000 runs, configurable volatility)Yes
Historical backtestingYes, since 1872 (Shiller data)Yes
Tax modelingUS federal, state and payroll, standard deduction onlyYes (Premium)
Roth conversionsYes: fill a bracket, fixed, or under the ACA limitYes (Premium)
Scenario compare modeUp to 5 plans, summary tableYes (Premium)
Multi-currency9 currencies, locale formattingDisplay currency only (symbol, no conversion)
Data storageYour browser; a free account is optionalCloud, account required
Multiple plans at $0Yes, up to 5No (Premium)
Sankey cash-flow diagramYesNo
Survival heatmapYesNo
Stress test scenarios6 built-in, plus a Social Security cutVia manual what-ifs (Premium)
Withdrawal strategies3 + age-59.5 ruleConfigurable withdrawal order
Mobile experienceFull feature setDesktop-first
Monte Carlo chart: a fan of simulated portfolio paths for a 65-year-old with $1,000,000 drawing 4% a year ($3,333 a month, raised with inflation) for 30 years, 5% real return, 15% yearly swings. The money lasted in 394 of 500 simulations. Middle 80% and median in today's dollars: at 70, $624k to $1.5M (median $977k); at 80, $263k to $2.4M (median $903k); at 90, $0 to $3.1M (median $785k). Replayed through history it lasted in 121 of 125 start years.
The Monte Carlo fan both tools draw for free: $1M drawing 4% lasted in 394 of 500 simulated markets on firenum's planner. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

The Simulation Engines Are Closer Than You'd Think

Both tools run drift-corrected Monte Carlo and both backtest against real historical returns. Both do the same job on the math that decides whether your plan survives. The bigger difference is between the methods, not the tools: Monte Carlo grades a plan by the return and swing you assume, while a backtest grades it by what markets actually did.

Line chart of Monte Carlo vs historical backtest by withdrawal rate for $1,000,000 over 30 years, the withdrawal raised with inflation. Monte Carlo at 5% real return with 15% swings, simulations that lasted of 500: 3% 463, 3.5% 438, 4% 394, 4.5% 346, 5% 284, 5.5% 238, 6% 199. Backtest, start years that lasted of 125 (1872 to 1996): 124, 123, 121, 119, 110, 93, 82.
At 4%, 394 of 500 simulations lasted (79%) against 121 of 125 start years (97%). Monte Carlo drew around 8% a year before inflation; the S&P 500 returned 9.4% since 1871. The model moves the answer more than the tool. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

firenum documents its full methodology with derivations if you want to check the work. Both now run US taxes inside the engine. The differences that matter are around it: tax depth and polish on their side, privacy and currency handling on ours.

The Honest Answer: Many People Should Use Both

These tools charge differently because they're built differently. ProjectionLab pays a team through subscriptions and gives you tax-aware depth in return. firenum runs the math in your browser, so one more planner costs it next to nothing, and gives you privacy and breadth in return. A workflow I genuinely recommend:

Verdict

If your US taxes are complicated (itemizing, head of household, a city income tax), pick ProjectionLab; our full ProjectionLab review rates it 4.5/5. If you want private, multi-currency planning with everything saved and nothing paid, pick firenum. If you're serious about early retirement, the combined cost of using both is $0 to $129 a year, which is a rounding error against the decisions they'll improve.

See the firenum side of the comparison yourself.