The Honest Truth

There are dozens of FIRE calculators. Some cost $100+/year. Some have features we don't. Here's an honest comparison so you can pick the right tool for your needs.

Heatmap of years to FIRE by withdrawal rate (rows 3%, 3.5%, 4%, 4.5%, 5%) and real return (columns 3% to 7%) for a 30-year-old spending $4,000 a month with $50,000 invested and saving $2,000 a month. At a 3% withdrawal rate: 35, 31, 28, 26, 24 years. At 3.5%: 32, 29, 26, 24, 22. At 4%: 29, 26, 24, 22, 20. At 4.5%: 27, 24, 22, 20, 19. At 5%: 25, 23, 21, 19, 18. The FIRE calculator's defaults, 4% and 5%, give 24 years.
Why FIRE calculators disagree: the same saver needs anywhere from 18 to 35 years depending on the withdrawal rate and return each tool assumes. Check those two inputs before comparing answers. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

We built firenum.com because we wanted something specific: a fast, private, multi-currency set of calculators that works offline. That's our niche. Just want your retirement date? Try the FIRE calculator. Other tools excel at different things.

Research from Vanguard confirms what we've seen firsthand: "Investors who use financial planning tools report 25% higher confidence in their retirement readiness." The right calculator isn't just about features. It's about building confidence in your plan.

If an optimizer that picks your Social Security age or Roth conversions, or account aggregation, matters more to you than privacy and multi-currency support, there are better options. We'll tell you which ones. For Monte Carlo, historical backtesting, stress testing and US tax (federal, 50 states and DC, Social Security, a Roth ladder), firenum does all of that, free, with no account required. Comparing only the full retirement planners? See our retirement planner comparison, October 2026, with every price checked on the vendor's own page.

Quick Comparison

Feature firenum Engaging Data FI Calc ProjectionLab Boldin
Price Free Free Free $129/yr $168/yr
Account Required ✗ ✗ ✗ ✓ ✓
Multi-Currency ✓ 9 currencies ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗
Progress Tracking ✓ ✗ ✗ ✓ ✓
Stress Test Scenarios ✓ 6 scenarios ✗ ✓ via backtesting ✓ ✓
One-Time Events ✓ ✗ ✗ ✓ ✓
Monte Carlo ✓ 100-5,000 runs ✓ ✗ ✓ ✓
Historical Backtesting ✓ Since 1872 ✗ ✓ 100+ years ✓ ✗
Cash Flow Visualization ✓ Sankey diagram ✗ ✗ ✓ ✗
Withdrawal Strategies ✓ 3 + 59.5 rule ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
Portfolio Survival Heatmap ✓ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗
US Tax Modeling ✓ 50 states, Roth ladder ✗ ✗ ✓ ✓
Mobile-First ✓ ~ ✓ ✓ ~
Works Offline ✓ ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗
No Account Needed ✓ saved in your browser; free account optional ✓ ✓ ✗ ✗

What firenum Does Best

Monte Carlo Simulation

100-5,000 runs with drift-corrected lognormal returns, configurable volatility, and customizable parameters. Get how often the money lasts and percentile bands. Boldin keeps Monte Carlo in PlannerPlus ($168/year).

Historical Backtesting

Every starting period since 1872 using Shiller S&P 500 data. One run per January the data covers (105 historical starting years for a 50-year projection, 125 for a 30-year one), with worst/best case outcomes and a portfolio survival heatmap. See how your plan would have survived every US market since 1871.

Cash Flow Visualization

Sankey diagram showing where one year's money goes, for any full year of the plan: income, spending, debt payments, savings into each account, and the accounts you draw on in retirement. Switch between the year's sums and its average month.

Stress Test Scenarios

6 built-in scenarios: market crash (timing, severity, years of slower growth), lower returns, income loss, spending spike, high inflation (with duration), and retiring earlier or later. See how your plan holds up when things go wrong.

Multi-Currency Support

9 currencies: USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, CHF, JPY, INR, NZD. Most FIRE calculators are US-only. If you live outside the US or hold assets in multiple currencies, this matters.

One-Time Events

Model windfalls, inheritance, home sales, or large purchases at specific future dates. See exactly how a $50k bonus in 3 years or a $200k home sale at retirement changes your trajectory.

Private by Default

No account needed. The planner runs in your browser and your plan is saved there; a free account keeps it on any device. Works offline too.

Bar chart of historical backtest start years by retirement length in the Fire Planner (January starts since 1872, Shiller S&P 500 data), with the windows that share no year: 10 years 145 start years, 15 independent; 20 years 135, 7; 30 years 125, 5; 40 years 115, 3; 50 years 105, 3; 60 years 95, 2.
A 60-year backtest grades 95 start years, but 154 full years of history hold only 2 windows that share no year. Neighbouring start years live through mostly the same markets, so read a backtest count as history replayed, not as independent trials. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

Plus: 13 calculators in one place, mobile-first design, dark/light themes, no ads, sub-second load times.

Where Competitors Excel

Let's be honest about our limitations. These tools do things we don't:

Tax Optimization

firenum now computes US federal tax, state tax for all 50 states and DC, and payroll tax every year, and runs a Roth conversion ladder on one of four rules you pick (fill the 10, 12, 22 or 24% bracket, a fixed amount, or up to the ACA limit). What it leaves out: itemized deductions, AMT, local tax, IRMAA and tax-loss harvesting. Pralana adds local tax and IRMAA and optimizes withdrawal order. MaxiFi searches for the Roth conversions with the lowest lifetime tax. ProjectionLab Premium does capital gains harvesting.

Account Aggregation

Empower (formerly Personal Capital) pulls balances from all your accounts automatically. Convenient if you have accounts spread across many institutions.

Social Security Optimization

firenum now takes your statement's benefit and a claiming age from 62 to 70, adds the spousal top-up and taxes the benefit. You compare claiming ages yourself across up to 5 plans. MaxiFi (Social Security Maximizer) and Pralana search for the best age for you, and Boldin PlannerPlus has a Social Security explorer. firenum also skips survivor benefits and the earnings test.

Detailed Competitor Reviews

Free Tools

Engaging Data

Free

Best for: Monte Carlo simulations

Strengths

  • Detailed Monte Carlo analysis
  • Multiple withdrawal strategies
  • Social Security integration

Limitations

  • US-focused
  • Single currency
  • No progress tracking
Visit Engaging Data →

FI Calc

Free

Best for: Historical backtesting

Strengths

  • 100+ years of historical data
  • Multiple portfolio strategies
  • Variable spending models

Limitations

  • US market data only
  • Single currency
  • No ongoing tracking
Visit FI Calc →

cFIREsim

Free

Best for: Community-validated simulations

Strengths

  • Long-standing community tool
  • Flexible spending rules
  • Historical analysis

Limitations

  • Dated interface
  • US-only
  • No mobile optimization
Visit cFIREsim →

WalletBurst

Free

Best for: Clean visualizations

Strengths

  • Beautiful charts
  • FIRE timeline calculator
  • Savings rate focus

Limitations

  • Fewer calculator types
  • US-focused
  • Limited customization
Visit WalletBurst →

InvestToFire

Free

Best for: Pension and VA income holders

Strengths

  • Subtracts pension/VA/side income from your FIRE number
  • Inflation-correct Coast FIRE math
  • Year-by-year US withdrawal tax planner

Limitations

  • USD only
  • Inputs reset on reload
  • Fixed-return projections (no Monte Carlo)
Visit InvestToFire →

We tested InvestToFire's three strongest calculators hands-on and verified the math to the dollar. Full write-up: InvestToFire review.

Honorable mention: FIRE Calculator HQ. A set of single-purpose coast FIRE calculators, with separate versions for couples, a pension and Social Security, plus barista, lean and fat FIRE. Use it when you want one coast number fast. The ebook and workbook it sells are optional. The calculators work without them.

Paid Tools

ProjectionLab

$129/year (Premium)

Best for: Best overall paid option

Strengths

  • Comprehensive scenario planning
  • Monte Carlo + historical
  • Tax-aware projections
  • Beautiful interface

Limitations

  • Subscription cost
  • Learning curve
  • Account required
Visit ProjectionLab →

Boldin (NewRetirement)

$168/year (PlannerPlus)

Best for: Account linking and classes

Strengths

  • State and federal tax projections
  • Social Security and Roth conversion explorers
  • Links accounts through three aggregators

Limitations

  • Higher cost
  • US tax-focused
  • Many inputs for a basic plan
Visit Boldin (NewRetirement) →

Pralana

$99/year (Gold)

Best for: Tax detail and optimizers

Strengths

  • Optimizes Social Security start ages and withdrawal order
  • Federal, state and local tax, IRMAA, ACA (Online)
  • Monte Carlo and historical analysis

Limitations

  • Gold runs in Excel
  • Steep learning curve
  • Online edition's price not published
Visit Pralana →

Empower (Personal Capital)

Free tools (advisory from 0.89% AUM)

Best for: Account aggregation

Strengths

  • Free account aggregation
  • Fee analyzer
  • Investment checkup

Limitations

  • Pushes advisory services
  • Privacy concerns
  • Free tier limited
Visit Empower (Personal Capital) →

Spreadsheets

Sometimes a spreadsheet is the right tool. These are the best free FIRE spreadsheets:

Mad Fientist FI Spreadsheet

The gold standard free FIRE spreadsheet. Comprehensive tracking with clear instructions.

Download →

Big ERN SWR Toolbox

Deep safe withdrawal rate analysis. Best for understanding sequence-of-returns risk.

Download →

How to Choose

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources:

  • Feature comparison based on direct testing of each tool, February 2026
  • Prices for ProjectionLab, Boldin, Pralana and Empower checked on each vendor's own pricing page, October 19, 2026 (sources in our retirement planner comparison). Other tools: February 2026
  • Vanguard: research on financial planning tool confidence

This article is for informational purposes only. We are not affiliated with any of the tools reviewed.