TL;DR

  • Morningstar's 2026 number: 3.9% safe starting rate (up from 3.7%)
  • Flexible spending pushes the safe rate to ~5-6%
  • For FIRE: 4% works for 30 years; use 3.0-3.5% for 50-year horizons
  • Bottom line: The 4% rule isn't dead. It's a starting point, not a suicide pact.

Want the deep dive? Read our full 4% Rule Guide for the history, math, and practical application.

What Morningstar Actually Said

Every year, Morningstar publishes updated retirement income research. Their 2026 report sets the safe starting withdrawal rate at 3.9% for a 30-year retirement with a 90% success probability.

That's up from 3.7% in their previous analysis. The reason: modestly higher expected returns from current market valuations and bond yields. Nothing dramatic. Just the math doing its thing.

Morningstar's number is a forecast. History was kinder. Here is how often each rate lasted 30 years in every January start from 1872 to 1996 in our backtest: all S&P 500 with dividends, the withdrawal raised with inflation every year.

Withdrawal Rate Lasted 30 Years (125 starts) What It Means
3.5% 125 of 125 Never ran out over 30 or 40 years; over 50, only 1969 did
4.0% 123 of 125 The classic Bengen rule: only 1966 and 1969 ran out
4.5% 118 of 125 Getting risky for fixed withdrawals
5.0% 106 of 125 Only viable with flexible spending

The headline "3.9% not 4%" makes for good financial media drama. In reality, the difference between 3.9% and 4.0% on a $1,500,000 portfolio is $125/month. That's a grocery trip.

Bengen himself has pushed back on the doom-and-gloom framing. As he told the Journal of Financial Planning: "The 4 percent rule is actually the safe withdrawal rate for a worst-case scenario in history. If you're willing to be flexible, it's probably too conservative."

Bar chart of the highest withdrawal rate that lasted 30 years for each retirement start year from 1872 to 1996, all S&P 500 with dividends and the withdrawal raised with inflation. The worst start, 1969, allowed 3.81%; 1966 allowed 3.92% and 1968 4.07%. The median start allowed 7.71% and the best, 1949, 14.33%.
Bengen's worst case, start year by start year: the worst year to retire since 1872, 1969, allowed 3.81% for 30 years. The median start allowed 7.71%. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

The real story isn't the 0.1% difference. It's what happens when you stop treating this number as gospel and start building flexibility into your plan.

The Flexible Spending Game-Changer

The 4% rule assumes the worst possible behavior: you withdraw the exact same inflation-adjusted amount every year, regardless of what markets do. Portfolio drops 40%? Keep withdrawing. Portfolio doubles? Withdraw the same.

Nobody actually does this.

Morningstar's research shows that flexible spending strategies can safely support 5-6% starting withdrawal rates. Here are the three main approaches:

1. Constant Percentage Method

Withdraw a fixed percentage of your current portfolio each year. If your portfolio drops, you spend less. If it grows, you spend more.

The catch: your income is volatile. A 30% market crash means a 30% pay cut. That's fine if you have spending flexibility. It's not fine if every dollar is committed to fixed expenses.

2. Endowment Method (10-Year Rolling Average)

Withdraw a percentage of your portfolio's 10-year rolling average value. This smooths out the volatility. You don't get the full benefit of bull markets immediately, but crashes don't slash your income overnight.

University endowments use this approach for a reason: it works. Morningstar's data suggests this method supports a starting withdrawal rate of approximately 5.4%.

3. Guardrails Strategy

Set upper and lower spending limits. When your portfolio grows enough that your withdrawal rate drops below the floor (say 3.5%), you give yourself a raise. When it drops enough that your rate exceeds the ceiling (say 5.5%), you cut back.

This is probably the most practical approach for early retirees. You get predictable income most of the time, with adjustments only when things get extreme.

All three approaches share one insight: the willingness to spend less when markets are bad is worth more than any asset allocation decision you'll ever make.

Christine Benz, Morningstar's director of personal finance and retirement planning, put it simply: "The starting withdrawal rate matters far less than your willingness to adjust spending along the way. Flexibility is the single most powerful lever retirees have."

A different idea drops portfolio value as the yardstick. Adam Woods at Thousandaire argues for planning around the earnings of the companies you own: a stock is a slice of a business, so the business's earnings are what fund your spending. Market prices swing far more than earnings do, so a plan built this way flinches less when a crash hits.

The Plot Twist: Retirees Are Spending Too Little

While the internet argues about whether 3.9% or 4.0% is the "right" number, the bigger risk for many retirees runs the other way: they spend too little.

The underspending problem is real. People who spent decades accumulating wealth often can't flip the switch to spending it. They die with portfolios larger than what they retired with. Their heirs get the money. Their younger selves got the anxiety.

Research from the Employee Benefit Research Institute confirms it: "Retirees with $500,000 or more at retirement still had, on average, 88% of their pre-retirement assets remaining after 18 years." The money piles up unspent.

There's a clinical name for this: money anxiety. And it doesn't care how much you have saved. The fear of running out doesn't correlate with the probability of running out.

If you're going to worry about a withdrawal rate problem, it might be the opposite one you expected: not spending too much, but spending too little. The risk isn't poverty in old age. It's an impoverished life along the way.

What This Means for FIRE

The original 4% rule was designed by William Bengen in 1994 and validated by the Trinity Study in 1998. Both assumed a 30-year retirement starting at age 65.

If you're retiring at 35, you need your money to last 50-60 years, not 30. That changes the math. A 4% draw on your own number: the Monte Carlo retirement calculator grades it in 500 runs and every start year since 1872.

Longer horizons need lower rates

For a 50-year retirement, most researchers recommend a starting withdrawal rate of 3.0-3.5%. That translates to a FIRE multiplier of roughly 28-33x your annual expenses instead of the standard 25x.

Retirement Length Safe Withdrawal Rate Multiplier FIRE Number ($60k/yr)
30 years (traditional) 3.9-4.0% 25x $1,500,000
40 years (retire at 50) 3.4-3.6% 28x $1,680,000
50 years (retire at 40) 3.0-3.3% 30-33x $1,800,000-$2,000,000
60 years (retire at 35) 2.8-3.0% 33-36x $2,000,000-$2,160,000

What history says

Those recommendations leave a margin for a future worse than the past. The past itself was kinder. We ran every January start since 1872 through our backtest: all S&P 500, the withdrawal raised with inflation every year. 4% lasted 30 years in 123 of 125 starts (1966 and 1969 ran out), and 60 years in 95% of them. 3% never ran out at any length.

Heatmap of historical safe withdrawal rates by retirement length, all S&P 500 from 1872. Over 30 years: 3% and 3.5% lasted 100% of the time, 4% 98%, 4.5% 94%, 5% 85%, 5.5% 78%, 6% 72%. Over 40 years: 4% lasted 95%. Over 50 years: 92%. Over 60 years: 3% and 3.5% lasted 100%, 4% 95%, 4.5% 83%, 5% 77%, 5.5% 65%, 6% 54%.
Safe withdrawal rate by retirement length, from U.S. market history since 1871. The table above is more cautious on purpose. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

But FIRE has built-in advantages

Early retirees aren't actually comparable to traditional retirees in several important ways:

Want to model this yourself? Our Retirement Projector lets you adjust return rates, time horizons, and contributions to see exactly how the math plays out.

Our Take

After digging through the research, here's our honest assessment:

Use 4% (25x) as your planning target. It's close enough to Morningstar's 3.9% that the difference doesn't matter, and it's a clean number that's easy to calculate with. If you're spending $50,000/year, target $1,250,000.

Build in flexibility, not a bigger number. The difference between a 3.5% and 4% withdrawal rate on $60,000/year spending is $214,000 more you need to save. That could be 2-3 extra years of work. Instead, develop the skill of adjusting spending. Cut discretionary expenses 15-20% when markets crash. That flexibility is worth more than a bigger portfolio.

Track your actual spending. Most people don't know what they really spend. They know their income, their rent, their car payment, but not the full picture. Without knowing your real number, any withdrawal rate is a guess. Our Fire Planner helps you monitor this over time.

Don't let the perfect rate paralyze you. The real risk for most people pursuing FIRE isn't withdrawing 4.0% instead of 3.9%. It's spending an extra decade working a job they hate because they couldn't decide between 25x and 28x. Run the numbers, build a plan, and adjust as you go.

For the full history and math behind the 4% rule, see our comprehensive guide. For the research sources we rely on, check our References page.

Frequently Asked Questions