TL;DR

  • US inflation is 3.7% (12 months to September 2026), up from 2.4% in February; it peaked at 4.2% in May. Most of it is energy: core inflation is 2.6%.
  • In 154 years of US data, 8 of 105 fifty-year retirements ran out of money at a 4% withdrawal rate. 5 of the 8 started in a high-inflation decade (1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1973). The others were 1906, 1907 and 1929.
  • High inflation alone wasn't the problem. Stocks returned 7.6% a year above inflation through the 1940s. The killer was high inflation plus flat stocks, as in 1966–1982.
  • A simple rule saved every failed start year: skip the inflation raise after a year your portfolio loses money, and catch up once it recovers. The cost is real: a 1966 retiree would have spent 20% less on average.

The 4% rule raises your withdrawal with inflation every year. That's what makes it safe in normal times and what makes it dangerous in a bad inflationary decade. When prices rise 7% a year and stocks go nowhere, your withdrawals climb while the portfolio shrinks. To see how often that has actually broken an early retirement, we replayed every start year since 1872.

Where inflation is right now

MeasureLatestSource
US CPI, 12 months to September 20263.74%BLS, CPI-U
Core CPI (no food or energy), same 12 months2.56%BLS, CPI-U
Market's 10-year inflation forecast (breakeven)2.36%FRED
Brent crude, September average$101/barrelArbat Capital
Fed funds rate3.75–4.00%, raised in SeptemberSchwab
Inflation rate by year graph, US CPI December to December, 1872 to 2025: inflation averaged 2.1% a year. The 1970s had seven years above 5%. Peaks: 1918 20.4%, 1946 18.1%, 1979 13.3%, 2021 7.0%. Prices fell in 33 years, the last in 1954; 2025 was 2.7%.
US inflation by year since 1872. It averaged 2.1% a year, and the 1970s had seven years above 5%. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

The gap between headline and core says this is mostly an oil shock, not inflation spreading through the whole economy. Bond markets expect it to settle near 2.4% over ten years. They expected roughly the same in 2021, the year before inflation hit 9%. A plan should survive the case where the market is wrong.

What 154 years of data show

The method: 100% US stocks (S&P 500 total return) from the Shiller dataset, a 4% first-year withdrawal raised with actual CPI every January, every start year from 1872. It's the same model as the survival heatmap in the Fire Planner. We call a start year "high inflation" when CPI averaged 5% or more over its first ten years: 1909–1916, 1938–1942 and 1965–1980.

Retirement lengthHigh-inflation startsAll other startsFailed start years
30 years27 of 29 (93%)96 of 96 lasted1966, 1969
40 years24 of 29 (83%)85 of 86 (99%)1929, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1973
50 years20 of 25 (80%)77 of 80 (96%)1906, 1907, 1929, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1973

For a traditional 30-year retirement, the only two failures in this model, 1966 and 1969, started in high inflation. For a 40- to 50-year early retirement, high-inflation starts were 5 of the 6 failures at 40 years and 5 of the 8 at 50.

This model takes the withdrawal at year end, after that year's return, priced at that date's CPI, and charges no fees. Taken at the start of each year instead, 4% lasts 30 years from 122 of 125 starts rather than 123: 1929 fails too. The pattern of which years fail is the same (see our 4% rule review).

Inflation plus flat stocks is what kills a plan

Period (January to January)Inflation / yearStocks after inflation / year
1941–19525.9%+7.6%
1966–19827.0%−1.0%
1973–19838.7%−2.0%
1872–2026 (all)2.1%+7.1%

Each period runs from January of the first year to January of the last, S&P 500 total return with dividends, on the same Shiller data as the backtest.

Stagflation 1970s chart: US inflation and S&P 500 return after inflation for each year from 1966 to 1981, January to January. Inflation averaged 7.0% a year and never fell below 3.3%; stocks averaged −1.0% a year after inflation, with losses of 24% in 1973 and 34% in 1974, so $1 bought 85 cents of goods 16 years later.
Stagflation, January 1966 to January 1982: inflation every year, and stocks lost 1.0% a year after it. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

A 1941 retiree saw inflation almost as high as a 1966 retiree's and ended up with six times their starting portfolio after inflation. The difference was what stocks did. A 1966 retiree on the 4% rule had 44% of their starting portfolio left in real terms after ten years, and 24% after sixteen. They were still withdrawing the full inflation-adjusted 4% of the original amount, which by then was over 16% of what was left.

Inflation and retirement chart: real portfolio of two retirees on the 4% rule, 100% S&P 500, over 40 years. Both met high inflation in their first ten years (6.1% and 5.7% a year). The January 1941 retiree had 1.2 times the start after 10 years, 8.0 times at the peak in year 32 and 6.0 times at year 40. The January 1966 retiree had 44% left after 10 years, 24% after 16 and ran out in year 29.
Same inflation, opposite endings. In their first ten years stocks returned +6.3% a year after inflation for the 1941 retiree and −2.5% for the 1966 retiree. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

That's sequence-of-returns risk in its purest form. Inflation doesn't need to be worse than the 1940s to hurt you. It only needs to arrive with a decade of flat stocks.

The fix: make your raises conditional

We tested one rule: after a calendar year in which the portfolio lost value before withdrawals, skip that January's inflation raise. Once the portfolio is back above its starting value in real terms, go back to the full inflation-adjusted amount.

Rule at 4%40 years50 years
Always raise with inflation109 of 115 lasted97 of 105 lasted
Skip raises after a losing year, catch up later115 of 115105 of 105
Always raise, but start at 3.5%115 of 115104 of 105 (1969 ran out)

The skip rule saved every start year; 3.5% saved all but 1969 over 50 years. They cost different people different amounts. Spending after inflation over 40 years, as a % of a fixed 4% withdrawal:

Start yearSkip-raise rule: average spendingSkip-raise rule: lowest year3.5% from day one
194198%82%87.5% every year
196680%60%87.5% every year
197387%70%87.5% every year

Starting at 3.5% means a 14% bigger FIRE number, saved for in advance, whether or not the bad decade comes. A $40,000-a-year plan needs $1.14M instead of $1M. The skip-raise rule lets you retire on the smaller number, and you only pay if things go badly. In 1966 the bill was steep: in its worst year spending fell to 60% of the full real amount. In most other years you'd barely notice it.

The 60% sounds frightening, but cuts like that build up over years of falling real values, and that's where flexibility pays off. Someone who retired at 45 can pick up part-time work, cut travel or move somewhere cheaper well before that point. Someone who retired at 65 has fewer of those options. That's why the rule matters more for FIRE than for traditional retirement.

Five more ways to prepare

1. Lock in the first decade with inflation-protected bonds

The first ten years carry most of the sequence risk. 10-year TIPS pay 2.91% on top of inflation, the most since 2008. A TIPS ladder covering your first years pays out in inflation-adjusted dollars whatever stocks do. We covered the numbers in FIRE with 5% bonds. In the US, I bonds are an inflation-linked option too, capped at $10,000 per person per year.

2. Keep a fixed-rate mortgage

Inflation shrinks a fixed debt in real terms. A 3% mortgage taken out in 2021 is costing you less than nothing after inflation right now. Don't rush to pay it off: put spare cash in T-bills at 4.25% instead. A variable-rate loan is the opposite. It goes up with rates, so fixing or paying it down is a priority.

3. Use your own inflation rate, not the headline

CPI is an average basket. A FIRE household that cycles, cooks at home and owns its home outright sees less of the energy shock than a commuter who rents. One whose health insurance renews this autumn will see more: ACA premiums are rising about 15% for 2027. Track your own spending for a year and you'll know which number applies to you.

4. Value income that's indexed to inflation

US Social Security rises with CPI each year; the 2027 increase is forecast at about 3.6%. Delaying a claim gets you a bigger inflation-protected check for life. Pensions without an inflation link lose roughly a third of their value over a decade at 4% inflation. Count them at a discount.

5. Don't hide in cash

Cash at 4.25% beats 3.7% inflation by less than 1% before tax. In 2022, T-bills paid about 2% while prices rose 6.5%. US stocks beat inflation in every 30-year period since 1872; the worst one still returned 3.3% a year after inflation. The answer to high inflation is a flexible spending plan, not a flight from stocks.

Run your own inflation test

The Fire Planner has a High inflation stress test. Set it to 7% for 16 years, starting the year you retire, roughly a 1966–1982 replay, and see whether the verdict changes. You can also give single expenses their own inflation rate: put health insurance or energy at 6% and keep the rest at the default. If the plan only survives without the stress test, decide now which raises you'd skip, so the choice is made before the bad year comes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Stress-test your plan against a 1970s replay.