Boldin and firenum solve different problems for different people. The short version: Boldin is the most thorough retirement-phase planner a consumer can buy, its flat-fee advisor access is one of the best deals in financial advice, and it asks for a level of commitment (time, data, and a US-centric worldview) that not everyone should give it.

What Boldin Is

Boldin, called NewRetirement until September 2024, started in 2015 when Stephen Chen built a spreadsheet to figure out whether his mom could retire. It's now a 50-person, VC-funded company with 250,000+ people planning with it (its pricing page, 07-11-2026) and more than $300B in assets. The consumer product is a detailed retirement planner; the business behind it increasingly sells white-label planning to banks, insurers, and employers like Nationwide and RTX.

Pricing

TierPriceWhat you get
Basic$0100+ inputs, 10+ charts, 2 interactive explorers, what-if scenarios. No Monte Carlo.
PlannerPlus$168/year250+ inputs, 25+ charts, Monte Carlo and stress testing, the Social Security and Roth conversion explorers, tax modeling, account linking, budgeter, plan monitoring with alerts. 14-day trial.
Boldin Advisors$3,200 flatSEC-registered, fee-only CFP advice: a comprehensive retirement plan checkup with a written plan, portfolio analysis, withdrawal strategy and Roth conversion recommendations. No AUM fees.

The price rose from $120 to $144 in July 2025 for new subscribers, and to $168 by October 2026. Tiers and prices above are from Boldin's pricing page on 07-11-2026. Existing users kept the old price. The free Basic tier gets 100+ inputs and two interactive explorers; Monte Carlo, the Social Security Explorer and the Roth conversion explorer are PlannerPlus features.

Where It Shines

Retirement-phase depth. Boldin models the decade-by-decade mechanics of actually being retired better than anything else in its price class: Social Security claiming strategies, Medicare and healthcare cost projections, RMDs, Roth conversions, pension options, annuities, home equity. If ProjectionLab is built for the accumulation-and-early-retirement crowd, Boldin is built for the "I'm 55 and this is real now" crowd.

Social Security optimization. The claiming-age explorer shows the lifetime value of different claiming strategies for singles and couples. For a couple with unequal earnings histories, the right claiming decision is worth tens of thousands of dollars, and Boldin makes that math visible in minutes.

Social Security age chart: the monthly check by claiming age from a $2,000 benefit at full retirement age 67 (born 1960 or later). Claim at 62 for $1,400 (70%), 63 $1,500 (75%), 64 $1,600 (80%), 65 $1,733 (86.7%), 66 $1,867 (93.3%), 67 $2,000 (100%), 68 $2,160 (108%), 69 $2,320 (116%), 70 $2,480 (124%).
The trade a claiming explorer weighs: 70% of the full benefit at 62, 100% at 67, 124% at 70. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

Flat-fee CFP access. Boldin Advisors charges a $3,200 flat fee for a comprehensive retirement plan checkup (pricing page, 07-11-2026). Compare that to a 1% AUM advisor on a $1.5M portfolio: $15,000 every single year. We wrote about when an advisor is worth it; flat-fee access wired directly into a planning tool you already use is a genuinely good model. If you would rather choose your own flat-fee planner, our fee-only advisor directory lists people who understand early retirement.

Plan monitoring. Link your accounts and Boldin tracks plan drift and sends alerts. It turns a one-time planning exercise into an ongoing practice, which is what most people's plans actually lack.

Where It Falls Short

The learning curve is real. 250+ inputs is a feature and a warning. First-time users routinely describe the onboarding as overwhelming, and the UI carries a decade of accumulated complexity. Plan a full weekend afternoon for initial setup, and expect to consult the (extensive) help content.

US-only in practice. The tax engine, Social Security, Medicare, and account types are all US constructs. Planners outside the US will fight the tool at every step.

Account linking means cloud data. The monitoring features require an account and, for full value, linked financial accounts. Boldin's enterprise customers (banks, insurers) hold it to serious security standards, and it's still a different privacy posture than local-only planning.

Accumulation-phase FIRE modeling is not the focus. Coast FIRE math, aggressive savings-rate scenarios, and early-retirement drawdown before 59.5 are all possible, and all feel like guests in a house built for traditional retirees.

The bridge to 59½ is where an early retiree needs the math most, and the ladder beats the penalty by a wide margin. On the default of our Roth conversion ladder calculator (single, $40,000 a year from 45, no other income), ten rungs cost $26,200 in federal tax. Taking the same money out early with the 10% penalty costs $66,200.

Line chart of total federal cost by age for ten $40,000 Roth conversion ladder rungs converted at ages 45 to 54, single filer, no other income: the ladder costs $2,620 a rung, $26,200 in all, while withdrawing the same money early with the 10% penalty costs $66,200, $40,000 more. Ages 45 to 49 need a $200,000 bridge.
A Roth conversion ladder on $40,000 a year costs $26,200 in federal tax over ten rungs; withdrawing early with the 10% penalty costs $66,200. Federal tax only, 2026 brackets. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

Who It's For

Who Should Skip It

Verdict: 4/5

Boldin earns its subscription for the audience it's built for: US planners near or in retirement who want the full picture and are willing to feed it. The point off is for complexity and the US-only worldview. If that's you, start with the Basic tier to see whether the inputs fit your life, then use the 14-day PlannerPlus trial on the Social Security and Roth conversion explorers before you pay $168/year.

Not in the US, or just want your number first?