What Is the 4% Rule?

The 4% rule is a guideline for how much you can safely withdraw from your investment portfolio each year in retirement without running out of money.

The rule says: Withdraw 4% of your portfolio in your first year of retirement. In subsequent years, withdraw that same dollar amount, adjusted for inflation.

Example:

In the Trinity Study (Cooley, Hubbard & Walz, 1998), a 50/50 stocks/bonds portfolio following this rule lasted 30 years in 95% of historical periods from 1926 to 1995. See the odds for your balance and spending on the Monte Carlo retirement calculator; the retirement withdrawal calculator gives the plain years.

Where It Came From

The 4% rule emerged from two key pieces of research:

William Bengen (1994)

Financial planner William Bengen published a paper analyzing how different withdrawal rates would have performed across every 30-year period in US market history, starting from 1926.

He found that a 4% initial withdrawal rate (adjusted for inflation each year) survived even the worst historical periods, including retirees who started right before the Great Depression or the stagflation of the 1970s. His portfolio was 50% large US stocks and 50% intermediate-term Treasuries.

The exact worst case came to about 4.15%, which he rounded to 4%. Later work that added small-company stocks raised his figure to 4.5% (his 2006 book Conserving Client Portfolios During Retirement) and, most recently, 4.7% (A Richer Retirement, 2025, which also adds mid-cap and international stocks).

The Trinity Study (1998)

Professors at Trinity University expanded on Bengen's work with more detailed analysis. They tested various withdrawal rates, time periods, and portfolio allocations (different mixes of stocks and bonds).

Their findings largely confirmed Bengen's: a 4% withdrawal rate with a diversified portfolio had a very high success rate over 30-year periods.

The study has been updated multiple times since, with similar conclusions.

How It Actually Works

Some important details that often get lost:

1. The 4% is only for year one.

You don't withdraw 4% of your current portfolio each year. You withdraw 4% of your starting portfolio, then adjust that number for inflation. This is crucial: your withdrawal amount doesn't drop when markets crash.

2. It assumes a specific portfolio.

The research typically assumes a 50-75% stocks, 25-50% bonds allocation. All-stock portfolios actually had lower success rates than balanced portfolios in some historical periods.

3. It's based on US market history.

The US stock market had exceptional returns in the 20th century. Other countries' markets have performed worse. This is both a feature and a bug (see criticisms below).

4. 30 years isn't forever.

The original research targeted a 30-year retirement. If you're retiring at 35 and expect to live to 90, that's 55 years. Longer time horizons require either more money or more flexibility.

The 25x Rule (Same Thing)

The 25x rule is just the 4% rule expressed differently.

If you can safely withdraw 4% per year, that means you need 100% ÷ 4% = 25 times your annual expenses.

This is how most FIRE planners calculate their target "FIRE number."

Bar chart of the rule of 25: the FIRE number is 25 times annual spending. $30,000 a year needs $750,000 (up to $840,000 at 28 times), $40,000 needs $1,000,000 (to $1,120,000), $50,000 needs $1,250,000, $60,000 needs $1,500,000, $80,000 needs $2,000,000, $100,000 needs $2,500,000 and $150,000 needs $3,750,000 (to $4,200,000).
The rule of 25 in U.S. dollars: 25 times a year of spending, or 28 times for a retirement of 50 years or more. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

The Criticisms

The 4% rule has plenty of critics. The main arguments:

"Future returns will be lower"

The 20th-century US market was unusually good. Stock valuations (like the CAPE ratio) are high. Some researchers argue that 3% or even 2.5% is more realistic for retirements starting today. That case also leaned on bond yields near record lows from 2012 to 2021; they have risen since 2022, and on 6 November 2026 the 10-year Treasury paid 4.86% and the 10-year TIPS 2.63% above inflation. What that changes: FIRE With 5% Bonds.

This is the most serious criticism. We don't know future returns, and the historical data may not predict them. For the current state of this debate, including Morningstar's latest safe-withdrawal estimate and what real retirees actually withdraw, see Is the 4% Rule Still Safe in 2026?

"30 years isn't long enough"

Early retirees might need 50-60 years of retirement. Longer time horizons have lower success rates. Someone retiring at 35 faces different math than someone retiring at 65.

History says the drop is smaller than the criticism suggests. In our backtest of every January start since 1872 (100% S&P 500 with dividends, from Robert Shiller's data; withdrawals raised each year with CPI inflation; no fees), 4% lasted 30 years every time and 60 years 96% of the time. 3.5% never ran out at any length. That is all stocks, not the 50-75% stock mix the research above assumes.

Heatmap of historical safe withdrawal rates by retirement length, all S&P 500 from 1872. Over 30 years: 3% to 4% lasted 100% of the time, 4.5% 95%, 5% 89%, 5.5% 81%, 6% 74%. Over 60 years: 3% and 3.5% lasted 100%, 4% 96%, 4.5% 87%, 5% 79%, 5.5% 67%, 6% 55%.
Safe withdrawal rate by retirement length: the share of historical retirements (100% S&P 500, every January since 1872) where the money lasted. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

"It's based on one country's history"

The US market was a winner in the 20th century. Japan's market took about 34 years to regain its 1989 peak (the Nikkei 225 price index passed it in February 2024), and a retiree drawing 4% from Japanese stocks starting in 1989 would have run out of money. Geographic diversification helps, but there's no guarantee the US stays exceptional.

"It ignores sequence of returns risk"

If the market crashes right after you retire, you're withdrawing from a depleted portfolio. Even if returns average out over time, bad returns early can doom a retirement. The 4% rule accounts for this historically, but past sequences may not predict future ones.

Line chart of sequence of returns risk: $1,000,000 in the S&P 500 with $45,000 a year withdrawn (a 4.5% rate, not 4%) and raised with inflation. Retiring in 1966, the money ran out in year 25 (1990). The same 30 annual returns in reverse order left $2.4 million after 30 years. Both orders averaged 4.9% a year after inflation.
Sequence of returns risk at a 4.5% withdrawal ($45,000 on $1,000,000): the 1966 retiree and the same returns run backwards. Only the order differs. Free to use under CC BY 4.0: credit firenum.com with a link.

"It's too rigid"

The rule assumes you withdraw the same inflation-adjusted amount regardless of market conditions. In reality, most retirees have some flexibility. They can cut spending in bad years, pick up part-time work, or delay major purchases.

The Defense

Despite the criticisms, many researchers and practitioners still think 4% is reasonable:

"The original research was conservative"

4% is what survived the worst start year in Bengen's 1994 data, not the typical one. His later research, with small-company and then mid-cap and international stocks added, put that worst case at 4.5% (2006) and 4.7% (2025). Measured against it, 4% has margin built in.

"Most people don't spend rigidly"

The failure scenarios assume robotic withdrawal regardless of market conditions. Real retirees adjust. They spend less in bad years, more in good years. With even modest flexibility, success rates increase dramatically.

"You'll probably have other income"

Social Security kicks in eventually. Pensions exist. Part-time work is possible. The 4% rule assumes your portfolio is your only income, which is conservative for most people.

"The research keeps getting updated"

Updated Trinity studies with more recent data still show high success rates for 4%. It has held up so far for retirees who started in 2008 and 2020, though they are only 18 and 6 years into a 30-year test.

"Perfect is the enemy of good"

Any withdrawal rate is a guess about the future. Analysis paralysis helps no one. 4% is a reasonable starting point that's well-studied and understood.

What Should You Actually Do?

Given the uncertainty, here's a practical approach:

1. Use 4% as your planning baseline.

It's well-researched and gives you a concrete target. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

2. Build in flexibility.

Plan to cut spending by 10-20% in bad market years. This dramatically increases success rates. If you can't cut at all, consider targeting 3.5% instead. The Fire Planner runs your own plan through every historical period since 1872, so you can see how much flexibility you actually need.

3. Keep some cash buffer.

Having 1-2 years of expenses in cash/bonds lets you avoid selling stocks during crashes. This reduces sequence-of-returns risk.

4. Don't retire on the razor's edge.

If your number is exactly 25x expenses, consider working another year or two. Some margin of safety reduces stress and increases odds of success.

5. Stay adaptable.

Monitor your portfolio. If things go badly in the first 5-10 years, adjust. Part-time work, spending cuts, or geographic arbitrage can all help. A rigid plan is a fragile plan.

6. Remember what the rule isn't.

The 4% rule isn't a guarantee. It's not a law of physics. It's a heuristic based on historical data that may or may not predict the future. Use it as a guide, not a religion.

Common Questions


The 4% rule is a starting point, not an ending point. It gives you a target to aim for and a framework for thinking about retirement sustainability. The actual number that works for you depends on your flexibility, time horizon, risk tolerance, and life circumstances.

Use it as a guide. Build in margins. Stay adaptable. And remember that perfect planning is impossible. Good enough is good enough.

Put it into a plan with your own numbers.